In case anyone cares what a housewife in Central Massachusetts thinks about war in Ukraine, I will say, I don't know.
I know that I am scarred by the total collapse of trust and honor in the news. On the one hand, disinformation, lack of trust. On the other, controlled opposition, designed to entrap the unsuspecting.
Meanwhile, here we are in the middle, in the dark, being asked to support rationalizations that could lead to WWIII and facing serious issues here at home while waiting for things to simmer down. And no, I don't think it's embarrassing to question how our standard of living suddenly tanked while some people in the world are facing worse. First, that disparity will always be true (whichever side of it we are on at the moment -- one entity's suffering is not cause for discounting the suffering of another, and it's possible that they are connected); second, it won't help anyone if we Americans are plunged into using our mental energy to cope with drastic changes in our day-to-day lives for no reason.
Prescinding from the question (a real one) of whether our prosperity was well derived and stewarded in the first place, the fact remains that there is something that doesn't ring true about its manner of being disrupted, with the inevitable burden on the poor, and the new crisis that we are virtually unilaterally being forced to sign on to, now that the old one has lost its grip.
That's all I've got. There's something not right about all of it.
Early articles to help with critical thinking while the information is being sorted out (if that ever happens), chosen with the hope of avoiding the two pitfalls, mentioned above. I don't claim that they do more than say, "I don't know!" with a healthy dose of "we must 'preach Christ and Him crucified'":
The Ukraine Mess: Points to ponder about narratives, criteria, possible responses by Fr. Jerry Pokorsky -- an outline, not an academic investigation, but important nonetheless. Just war criteria are not abstract idealisms but common-sense guides for prudent action, and as such, important to have in mind.
You'll need to have your sarcasm meter on for these; Jones and Zmirak are not endorsing, they are describing; Warren is observing and giving the only possible prescription:
Russia is Mordor, but the West is Sodom by Jason Jones and John Zmirak
The Path Out by David Warren
As I read more, I will share more.
Thank you for always providing links to the articles and points you reference.
ReplyDeleteThe West is Sodom. One reason I think our vets are taking their own lives after tours of duty is that they come home to not know what they fought for. I keep seeing kids brought up in good homes go absolutely leftist when they get to college and embrace the way of the world giving incense at every chance to the new religion. I'm honestly not sure what to think about this whole Russia/Ukraine thing, but I do know that Americans seem to be at loose ends without a crisis. We're good in crises, just not living normal lives.
ReplyDelete